These Citizens of Humanity Melanie jeans are still available in several sizes, so I thought I’d finally write up my official review of these wide-leg, cropped, high-waisted specimens. I acquired them more than a year ago, and since then, scores of wide-leg, cropped copycats have emerged. (And just in case the CoH site doesn’t have your size, I’ve listed some similar alternatives at the end of the post).
Brand: Citizens of Humanity
Style: Melanie Wide-Leg Crop
Fit and Fabric:
I’m historically a 28 in Citizens of Humanity, and I’ve been wearing this CoH since the brand launched in 2003. The Melanie’s are a little different because they are 100% cotton with zero stretch. I’m sorry I have to say they this but they are snug in the crotch. It’s just an unpleasant word (and an unpleasant feeling) but, alas, how else to describe it? It’s more noticeable while sitting, not so much while standing. The waist is 10 and 1/4 inches high and sits slightly below my belly button. I’m 5′ 4″ and the length hits right about at my ankles. They are a little snug in the thighs, and fit at the waist pretty well, although there is a slight gap after wearing them for several hours.
This silhouette in my opinion is extremely fun, though likely to be misunderstood by some. Certain heterosexual males might even consider them repellent. I believe they are the type of garment that inspired the Man Repeller blog. Still, if you care not whether heterosexual men or anyone else approve of your jeans, which I do not, they are refreshing, bohemian and substantial.
As I mentioned above, these jeans are rigid with no stretch, and therefore, unless you size up, aren’t a great choice for sitting all day or lengthy traveling on a plane, train or automobile. I do like the sturdy feel of these jeans, and they hold their shape nicely.
ALSO WEARING: Madewell leather tote, $178; bracelet is one-of-a-kind; jacket is old; Freda Salvador Comet ankle boots, $595, Osei Duro bolero from Mira (of Mira Mira) when she hosted a tag sale of pieces from her own closet at her store (I also scored this Valentino dress), the bag is courtesy Madewell and Goop (see it again here). The earrings are my all-time favorites from the Susquehanna Trading Post (more about that here), and I found these little turquoise and silver braid decorations at Melrose Trading post in L.A.
Jeans similar to the Malanies:
- Rachel Comey Legions
- Eve Denim Charlotte
- Stella McCartney scallop-lace trimmed jeans
- Agolde high rise sailor jeans
- Madewell wide-leg indigo jeans; Seafarer Harry jeans
- AG The Yvette wide-leg ankle jeans
- Current Elliot The Culotte Jean
- Mother undone hem maverick jeans
- Denim x Alexander Wang drill high-rise wide-leg jeans
JUST ARRIVED< >
SHOP PULL OVER
Ade Top at Shopbop
heart Rachel Antonoff Bessie Raglan Pullover
Contrast Check Sweater